The state's best D2 times were in separate venues this weekend -- most swam at the Small School Invitational, while DeForest, Sauk Prairie and Monona Grove took on Div. 1 Oregon and Badger-Big Foot at the Fort Atkinson Invitational.
DeForest cleaned up at Fort Atkinson in a meet (scored to 16 places, both A and B relays scoring) that played to the team's strength -- depth of talent. DeForest won just one event -- sophomore Casey Wolter in the 500 free -- and didn't finish higher than 3rd in any relay. But the Norskies depth carried them to a 462-397 over Oregon. Sauk edged MG for third place (306.5 to 288) behind a strong showing from sophomore Alison Meng, who won the 100 fly and finished second in the 100 back. MG's Hayley Martin continued her strong season, with wins in the 100/200 frees, and a come-from-behind anchor leg in the 200 free relay that gave the Silver Eagles a win in the event. MG, which has lost the last two 200 free relays at state by a combined time of .34 seconds, swam a 1:42.32, the fastest D2 time posted this year.
Over at Shorewood, two teams made a strong statement that they will be contenders at the state D2 meet -- Sturgeon Bay/Sevastopol and Grafton. They finished a close 1-2 at the meet, with SB/S edging Grafton by just three points, 271-268. McFarland finished third with 207.5 points, followed by Plymouth and Madison Edgewood. Traditional D2 powers Whitefish Bay, Shorewood and Whitnall finished 7th-through-9th.
For SB/S, strong showings in the relays helped cement 1st place, with a win in the 200 free relay and runner-up finishes in the medley and 400 free relays. Grafton was paced by junior standout Sadie Nenning, two-time defending state champ in the 100 back. She won both the back and the 100 fly (the latter in a thrilling race with Plymouth's Kate Criter and Shorewood's Elli Sellinger), and swam the leadoff leg's on Grafton's winning medley and 400 free relays.
Monday, October 20, 2008
D1 down the stretch
While Madison East and Madison Memorial took the weekend off from competition, Hartland-Arrowhead was busy dominating the field at the Highlander Invitational at Mequon-Homestead's pool. H-A won 8 of 11 events at the meet to win in a romp (405 points) over runner-up Waukesha South/Mukwonago (264) and third-place Middleton (228.5). Leading the way for H-A was freshman Haley Pietila (100/200 free victories) and sophomore Emma Goral, who continues to rack up impressive times a year after winning the D1 state title in the 100 fly. With its win, H-A moved up to second in the latest WISCA (state coaches association) poll, behind East and ahead of Memorial. H-A will certainly be the favorite in their tough Waukesha South/Mukwonago sectional Nov. 8; they are a very balanced team, with the real possibility of qualifying swimmers for state in each of the eight individual events, along with all three relays and at least one diver.
Tuesday, October 14, 2008
Fast freshmen
Every year, several freshmen make a big impact on the state high school swim scene -- a product, it seems, of girls maturing sooner as swimmers than boys (rare is the state title won in the boys divison by a freshman; it occurs frequently in girls swimming). Last year, it was Aja Van Hout of Madison East, Hartland-Arrowhead's Emma Goral, and Middleton's Katie Delaney making the big impact in D1, with Shorewood's Clare Chamberlain, Brookfield Academy's Kelsey Hojan-Clark, and Monona Grove's Kelsey Millin making a strong showing in D2.
This year, look for three freshmen in D1 to make a strong showing at sectionals and the state meet -- Hartland-Arrowhead's duo of Haley Pietila and Kate Jones, and Muskego's Jessica Wolf. Pietila has two times in the top three so far this season (200 and 100 frees), and could be a strong contender for the 200 free title, depending on who swims what at the sectional meets. Jones has a top-five time in the 100 back, and the two freshman and Goral are the reason H-A is considered a strong contender for the D1 state title it held for five straight years before finishing 5th last year. Wolf, meanwhile, has emerged as one of the top distance swimmers in the state, with top-five times in the 200 and 500 frees.
In D2, Plymouth's Kate Criter has made a sensational debut, with the state's leading breaststroke time so far this season (1:05.96, which would've won state last year), plus top-three times in the 50 free and 100 fly. Her coaches will have a tough decision to choose her two individual events for a Plymouth team that has climbed to 7th in the latest WISCA D2 poll and could surprise some folks at the sectional and state meets. Meanwhile, Anna Meinholz has joined big sister Ellie at Waukesha Catholic Memorial, currently ranked 9th. Anna has the third-best breaststroke time posted so far this season.
This year, look for three freshmen in D1 to make a strong showing at sectionals and the state meet -- Hartland-Arrowhead's duo of Haley Pietila and Kate Jones, and Muskego's Jessica Wolf. Pietila has two times in the top three so far this season (200 and 100 frees), and could be a strong contender for the 200 free title, depending on who swims what at the sectional meets. Jones has a top-five time in the 100 back, and the two freshman and Goral are the reason H-A is considered a strong contender for the D1 state title it held for five straight years before finishing 5th last year. Wolf, meanwhile, has emerged as one of the top distance swimmers in the state, with top-five times in the 200 and 500 frees.
In D2, Plymouth's Kate Criter has made a sensational debut, with the state's leading breaststroke time so far this season (1:05.96, which would've won state last year), plus top-three times in the 50 free and 100 fly. Her coaches will have a tough decision to choose her two individual events for a Plymouth team that has climbed to 7th in the latest WISCA D2 poll and could surprise some folks at the sectional and state meets. Meanwhile, Anna Meinholz has joined big sister Ellie at Waukesha Catholic Memorial, currently ranked 9th. Anna has the third-best breaststroke time posted so far this season.
State rankings
The latest state rankings are out from the WISCA (state high school coaches) website. The rankings are devised by assinging points to teams who have swimmers and relays in the top 30 time list compiled by WISCA (diving not included in the poll rankings). Here they are...
D1:
1) Madison Memorial; 2) Madison East; 3) Hartland-Arrowhead; 4) Waukesha South-Mukwanago; 5) Middleton; 6) Oregon; 7) Oshkosh West; 8) Appleton East; 9) Wauseu East; 10) Madison West.
No surprises here; Memorial, defending state champs East, and H-A have been the top teams all season long. The only mild surprise is Oregon, which swims against mainly D2 competition in the Badger South Conference but is D1 for state qualifying. The Panthers have a very good group of swimmers, and are the favorites for the conference title later this month. But their Middleton sectional is brutally difficult -- Memorial, East, West, Middleton and Verona all swim in the same sectional along with Oregon. The key for Oregon may be their relays -- they have the talent depth to qualify three relays for state. There is a good chance all five teams ranked ahead of them will qualify all three of their relay teams for state.
D2:
1) DeForest; 2) Milton; 3) Shorewood; 4) Baraboo; 5) Sauk Prairie; 6) Monona Grove; 7) Plymouth; 8) McFarland; 9) Waukesha Catholic Memorial; 10) Whitefish Bay.
The WISCA poll, based on top-30 times, heavily weights teams with considerable depth, and that's DeForest's strength. Few teams in D2 can boast the kind of depth that the Norskies can. Plus, the Norskies return a bevy of swimmers who have considerable experience at the state meet. The question for DeForest -- can their swimmers put up the top finishes needed at state to put them in the running for a third straight title? Right now, only one DeForest swimmer -- sophomore Casey Wolter in the 500 free -- has a top-five time in the statewide top-30 list. Meanwhile, Shorewood, Milton, Plymouth and Monona Grove all have swimmers with times in the top three of individual events.
One thing's for sure -- the Baraboo D2 sectional promises to be a barn-burner. Six of the top eight teams in the latest state poll swim there, plus an Edgewood team that finished 5th last year at state. It wouldn't be surprising to see individuals and relays placing 7th or even 8th at the sectional qualifying for state.
One more note -- the D2 poll probably understates the strength of Plymouth and unranked Grafton. Both teams will qualify some strong individuals and -- unlike most of the teams ranked ahead of them -- place some divers at the state meet.
D1:
1) Madison Memorial; 2) Madison East; 3) Hartland-Arrowhead; 4) Waukesha South-Mukwanago; 5) Middleton; 6) Oregon; 7) Oshkosh West; 8) Appleton East; 9) Wauseu East; 10) Madison West.
No surprises here; Memorial, defending state champs East, and H-A have been the top teams all season long. The only mild surprise is Oregon, which swims against mainly D2 competition in the Badger South Conference but is D1 for state qualifying. The Panthers have a very good group of swimmers, and are the favorites for the conference title later this month. But their Middleton sectional is brutally difficult -- Memorial, East, West, Middleton and Verona all swim in the same sectional along with Oregon. The key for Oregon may be their relays -- they have the talent depth to qualify three relays for state. There is a good chance all five teams ranked ahead of them will qualify all three of their relay teams for state.
D2:
1) DeForest; 2) Milton; 3) Shorewood; 4) Baraboo; 5) Sauk Prairie; 6) Monona Grove; 7) Plymouth; 8) McFarland; 9) Waukesha Catholic Memorial; 10) Whitefish Bay.
The WISCA poll, based on top-30 times, heavily weights teams with considerable depth, and that's DeForest's strength. Few teams in D2 can boast the kind of depth that the Norskies can. Plus, the Norskies return a bevy of swimmers who have considerable experience at the state meet. The question for DeForest -- can their swimmers put up the top finishes needed at state to put them in the running for a third straight title? Right now, only one DeForest swimmer -- sophomore Casey Wolter in the 500 free -- has a top-five time in the statewide top-30 list. Meanwhile, Shorewood, Milton, Plymouth and Monona Grove all have swimmers with times in the top three of individual events.
One thing's for sure -- the Baraboo D2 sectional promises to be a barn-burner. Six of the top eight teams in the latest state poll swim there, plus an Edgewood team that finished 5th last year at state. It wouldn't be surprising to see individuals and relays placing 7th or even 8th at the sectional qualifying for state.
One more note -- the D2 poll probably understates the strength of Plymouth and unranked Grafton. Both teams will qualify some strong individuals and -- unlike most of the teams ranked ahead of them -- place some divers at the state meet.
D2--Midway through the season
While D1 looks like a three-way race for the state title, D2 looks like a logjam. DeForest and Baraboo have been impressive in winning some invitationals (DeForest -- Fond du Lac, Baraboo its own invitational), while Shorewood, Whitefish Bay and Whitnall have all looked solid coming out of the Milwaukee suburbs (all three schools have swimmers who are likely contenders for state titles -- Shorewood's duo of Clare Chamberlain and Elli Sellinger, Whitefish Bay's Maggie Smith, and Whitnall's Liz Boshop). Meanwhile, Sturgeon Bay/Sevastopol has been putting up some solid performances, including the highest finish of any D2 team at the D1-heavy Wisconsin Invitational held earlier this season at the UW Natatorium. Last year's third-place finisher, Monona Grove, is led by sprinter Hayley Martin, who has the state's leading D2 times this year in the 50 and 100 frees, and Milton has had a solid year led by state champion Jennah Haney and senior Hailey Foss. Meanwhile, both Plymouth and Grafton have strong swimmers poised by qualifying for the state meet, and an added weapon -- divers who will likely qualify and score team points at the state meet.
The difficulty with predicting D2 this year is that so many of the defending champions in individual events -- DeForest's Kelly Winckler, New Berlin West's Beckie Thompson, and Greendale's Jenna Lennertz won five of the eight invidual events last year -- graduated, leaving a void to be filled. Several D2 teams have swimmers ready to take the place on the winner's podium; the winning team in D2 is likely to emerge from a squad that can put together a few top finishers in individual events, and qualify three relays for state.
The difficulty with predicting D2 this year is that so many of the defending champions in individual events -- DeForest's Kelly Winckler, New Berlin West's Beckie Thompson, and Greendale's Jenna Lennertz won five of the eight invidual events last year -- graduated, leaving a void to be filled. Several D2 teams have swimmers ready to take the place on the winner's podium; the winning team in D2 is likely to emerge from a squad that can put together a few top finishers in individual events, and qualify three relays for state.
Wednesday, October 1, 2008
Midway point of the season
We're halfway through the 2008 girls season, so here's a quick rundown of what to expect at the D1 and D2 state meets Nov. 14-15.
D1:
The race for the D1 team state title appears to be between last year's state champs (Madison East), East's Big Eight Conference rival and last year's runner-up (Madison Memorial), and the team whose five-year run as state champs was broken last year (Hartland Arrowhead). Call it a matchup among the few (East), the many (Memorial), and the young guns (Arrowhead).
East's chances of defending its title center on senior Ruby Martin and sophomore Aja Van Hout. Martin is the defending state champ in the 50 free, and with defending champ Stephanie Armstrong not swimming this year, the favorite in the 100 free. Van Hout is the defending state champ in the 200 IM and 500 free, and has been tearing through meets this season (setting four East High team records already). In short, they are probably the two best swimmers in the state; put them together on any two relays, and those relays are unlikely to lose, given the quality swimmers East can use to augment the duo. It's not inconceiveable to suggest East would go into the state meet favored to win six events (four individual events, two relays) -- that's 160 points right there, or a pretty good foundation upon which to defend the state title.
Memorial relies on depth and more depth, although junior Jackie Powell is a threat to win the D1 100 back title. The Spartans will certainly qualify three top relay teams for the state meet; their relays last year finished 1st, 2nd, and 3rd last year at state, and all but two of the swimmers on those relays return, augmented by some new additions to the team. Memorial may be the only D1 team in the state with a legitimate shot at qualifying a swimmer in each of the eight individual swimming events.
Arrowhead's been strengthened with an influx of freshmen, notably freestyler Haley Pietila and backstroker Kate Jones. They join sophomore Emma Goral, defending state champ in the 100 fly, to provide a solid core of young swimmers who will likely qualify with fast times for the state meet and form the foundation for the team's relays.
At the Wisconsin Invitational held in mid-September at the UW-Madison Natatorium, Arrowhead beat out Memorial 337-297, with East in third with 262 points. Two weeks later, however, Memorial turned the tables on Arrowhead at the Middleton Invitational, edging them by a 408-402.5 margin. Of course, down the stretch of the season, East and Memorial will face off three times in two weeks before the state meet -- their dual meet Oct. 22 at East, the Big Eight Conference meet Nov. 1, and the Middleton sectional Nov. 8.
D1:
The race for the D1 team state title appears to be between last year's state champs (Madison East), East's Big Eight Conference rival and last year's runner-up (Madison Memorial), and the team whose five-year run as state champs was broken last year (Hartland Arrowhead). Call it a matchup among the few (East), the many (Memorial), and the young guns (Arrowhead).
East's chances of defending its title center on senior Ruby Martin and sophomore Aja Van Hout. Martin is the defending state champ in the 50 free, and with defending champ Stephanie Armstrong not swimming this year, the favorite in the 100 free. Van Hout is the defending state champ in the 200 IM and 500 free, and has been tearing through meets this season (setting four East High team records already). In short, they are probably the two best swimmers in the state; put them together on any two relays, and those relays are unlikely to lose, given the quality swimmers East can use to augment the duo. It's not inconceiveable to suggest East would go into the state meet favored to win six events (four individual events, two relays) -- that's 160 points right there, or a pretty good foundation upon which to defend the state title.
Memorial relies on depth and more depth, although junior Jackie Powell is a threat to win the D1 100 back title. The Spartans will certainly qualify three top relay teams for the state meet; their relays last year finished 1st, 2nd, and 3rd last year at state, and all but two of the swimmers on those relays return, augmented by some new additions to the team. Memorial may be the only D1 team in the state with a legitimate shot at qualifying a swimmer in each of the eight individual swimming events.
Arrowhead's been strengthened with an influx of freshmen, notably freestyler Haley Pietila and backstroker Kate Jones. They join sophomore Emma Goral, defending state champ in the 100 fly, to provide a solid core of young swimmers who will likely qualify with fast times for the state meet and form the foundation for the team's relays.
At the Wisconsin Invitational held in mid-September at the UW-Madison Natatorium, Arrowhead beat out Memorial 337-297, with East in third with 262 points. Two weeks later, however, Memorial turned the tables on Arrowhead at the Middleton Invitational, edging them by a 408-402.5 margin. Of course, down the stretch of the season, East and Memorial will face off three times in two weeks before the state meet -- their dual meet Oct. 22 at East, the Big Eight Conference meet Nov. 1, and the Middleton sectional Nov. 8.
Wisconsin Invitational--prelims-final preview?
The second annual Wisconsin Invitational is in the books, and chief organizer Jason Verhelst (main swim job: head girls coach, D1 power Madison Memorial) pronounced it a success. The meet featured several top D1 and D2 teams, and was held at the UW-Madison Natatorium, site of the annual D1 and D2 state swim meets. More importantly, it served as a trial for something Verhelst would like to see implemented at the state meet: a preliminary-finals format.
"It's something we've been pushing for with the WIAA," Verhelst told the Wisconsin State Journal. "Thirty-five other states have prelims-finals (state meets) and somehow Wisconsin doesn't. So we're trying to demonstrate that you can run a quality prelims-finals meet in one day at the same venue that we hold state at."
The main argument in favor of a prelims-finals format at the state swim meet (beyond most states doing it) seems to be that it more closely parallels the experience that swimmers have during their non-high-school club seasons. All but the longest of races are swum prelims-finals during the club season, and it's a fair bet that most swimmers who have the ability to qualify for state -- certainly at the D1 level, and increasingly at the D2 level -- are swimming part of the year at the club level.
There are, however, several arguments that have been raised in swimming circles against a prelims-finals approach for the state meet. Chief among them is that is doesn't replicate what swimmers experience at the club level. High school swimming, goes this argument, is by design different than club swimming, and therefore the culmination of the high school season -- the state meet -- ought to be different than what's offered at the club level. In addition, it makes for a very long day for the swimmers, particularly the top swimmers. Madison East, last year's D1 state champs, had four swimmers last year qualify for the state meet in two individual events and two relays. That's potentially eight swims at a one-day meet for those swimmers.
"It definitely pushes your endurance to see how many times you can perform in a row," East staet champ Ruby Martin told the Wisconsin State Journal after the Wisconsin Invitational.
Expect to hear more about this idea at the WIAA level in the coming years.
"It's something we've been pushing for with the WIAA," Verhelst told the Wisconsin State Journal. "Thirty-five other states have prelims-finals (state meets) and somehow Wisconsin doesn't. So we're trying to demonstrate that you can run a quality prelims-finals meet in one day at the same venue that we hold state at."
The main argument in favor of a prelims-finals format at the state swim meet (beyond most states doing it) seems to be that it more closely parallels the experience that swimmers have during their non-high-school club seasons. All but the longest of races are swum prelims-finals during the club season, and it's a fair bet that most swimmers who have the ability to qualify for state -- certainly at the D1 level, and increasingly at the D2 level -- are swimming part of the year at the club level.
There are, however, several arguments that have been raised in swimming circles against a prelims-finals approach for the state meet. Chief among them is that is doesn't replicate what swimmers experience at the club level. High school swimming, goes this argument, is by design different than club swimming, and therefore the culmination of the high school season -- the state meet -- ought to be different than what's offered at the club level. In addition, it makes for a very long day for the swimmers, particularly the top swimmers. Madison East, last year's D1 state champs, had four swimmers last year qualify for the state meet in two individual events and two relays. That's potentially eight swims at a one-day meet for those swimmers.
"It definitely pushes your endurance to see how many times you can perform in a row," East staet champ Ruby Martin told the Wisconsin State Journal after the Wisconsin Invitational.
Expect to hear more about this idea at the WIAA level in the coming years.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)